Lege Trend. From the East. Compensating for Appraisal Costs +More

Virigina Senate passed SB 2403 (VA | 2019) that would allow for an award of just compensation plus costs in eminent domain proceedings.

What is the bill author saying?

  • “The pipeline companies should not get preferential treatment under our condemnation laws,”
  • “level the playing playing field”
  • This helps ” the landowner, the small business, or the farmer if a pipeline comes across their land.”

Virginia Mercury | Bill meant to level the playing field for pipeline takings passes Senate

Legal TREND. A new Kelo? Introduce yourself, Knick…

 Knick v. Township of Scott, Penn.  argued before the US Supremes this week is eminent domain and tort reform all in one.

The question is- do property owners have to exhaust all state courts for remedies before they being a case in federal court.

If the answer by the Supremes is No, then say adieu to Williamson County Regional Planning Commission v. Hamilton Bank of Johnson City. This is the case you hear about in evry legislative debate about eminent domain.

Why would Williamson County be…

Lege TREND. Quick Takes. Eminent Domain Just Compensation ACT.

Justin Amash (R-MI) filed the Eminent Domain Just Compensation ACT to prevent federal taking of land before final fair market value has been finalized.

So what would this impact?

  • potentially the amount of compensation for fair value determinations
  • when the land can be taken by the government
    • currently the land can be taken before a final determination of compensation
    • this bill requires a final determinationof compensation before the government can take possession (and presumably use) of…

+1 Local Government. No Eminent Domain for Private Gain. From the North.

Columbia County, Wisconsin Baord of Supervisors voted to support he following statewide eminent domain reform:

  • prohibit private companies from using eminent domain to take property
  • public good should not include economic growth
  • ensure that landowners can negotiate for a fair price.

Are other Wisconsin counties doing the same thing? Yes, at least 6

Portage Daily Register | Columbia County Board favors eminent domain reform

Sawyer County Record | Rusk County passes resolution calling for…

Legal TREND. Private Companies. Does Using Eminent Domain Subject you to State Open Records Laws?

Louisianna Courts are tackling whether a pipeline, that utilized eminent domain, subejcts its to open records laws.

The lower court said, no open records laws do not apply.

Next up: Appellate Courts. 

How is this moving through the courts? Via The Center for Constitutional Rights

What information is The Center for Constitutional Rights looking for?

  • company communications about federal, state and local politicians
  • documents concerning opposition to the pipeline
  • records related to LSU…

Legal TREND. Litigating Texas Kelo Fix. 2 Potential Fixes Heading to a Legislature near you.

In KMS RETAIL ROWLETT v. the City of Rowlett, the Texas Supreme Court this fall heard arguments over whether a road easement in a commercial development project violated the Texas Legislture’s legislative repsonse to Kelo v. City of New London.

The trial court and appellate court agreed that the roadway easement falls into  a transportation exception on the prohibtion against eminent domain for economic development purposes in Texas Government Code Sec. 2206.001

What legislative fixes could…

Refreshing our Recollection | READ THE BILL | Compensation for Local Government Ordinances that Affect Property Value

 

 

 

Michigan Legislature is considering HB4070 (2017-2018 | MI) which addresses land owner compensation in 3 ways:

  • Attorney Fees and Costs when a court determines a taking occurred
  • State Attorney General creates a list of governmental actions that results in a taking occurring
  • Can apply to rules, permits, applications and other governmental actions

Mackinac Center | House Bill 4070, Revise government eminent domain takings: Passed 76 to 31 in the House on March 28, 2017

 

 

Refreshing our Recollection | Disclosure of Building Defect Settlements | READ THE BILL

California Legislature passed SB 1465 (2018 | CA)  would require contractors:

  • to report settlements  concerning construction defects within 90 days
  • if settlements were for more than $1 million
  • concerned multifamily residences
  • The Contractors State License Board would hold the records

Daily Californian | Bills to increase balcony safety pass California State Legislature

Kelo Fix loophole. Cities Using Eminent Domain to Boost Revenues? WHERE. WHAT. HOW.

WHERE: Illinois

WHAT: Condemning swaths of property as “blighted” to redevelop the property as higher tax revenue. 

HOW is this happening when Illinois also prohibited eminent domain for economic development purposes? The blight designation in Illinois allows other neighboring, non-blighted properties to also be taken.

KPVI | Some Illinois cities eye eminent domain to boost revenue

Legal TREND. The US Supreme Court & Pipelines

The US Supreme Court may consider the Mountain Valley case.

What’s Mountian Valley about? Landowners are claiming the natural gas pipelines used eminent domain unconstitutionally because land is taken in states in which there is no benefit realized.

How did the landowners fare at the 4th Court of Appeals? landowners lost but because the court’s didn’t have jurisdiction not on the constititional issue.

 Washington Post | Landowners ask Supreme Court to hear Mountain Valley case