Category Archives: border

3 Points to Know. Eminent Domain v. Freedom of Religion

What is the Catholic Church on the Texas border, which will have a chapel in the border wall enforcement zone, saying about the use of eminent domains in its legal briefs?

  • Tantamount to requiring the church to participate in the building of a wall
  • the wall  is fundamentally inconsistent with Catholic ideology
  • Places an unjust burden on the freedom of religion

The Georgetown Voice | Georgetown Law Backs Catholic Diocese In Border Wall Proceedings

 

Lege TREND. Quick Takes. Eminent Domain Just Compensation ACT.

Justin Amash (R-MI) filed the Eminent Domain Just Compensation ACT to prevent federal taking of land before final fair market value has been finalized.

So what would this impact?

  • potentially the amount of compensation for fair value determinations
  • when the land can be taken by the government
    • currently the land can be taken before a final determination of compensation
    • this bill requires a final determinationof compensation before the government can take possession (and presumably use) of…

Legal TREND. Reality Check. Eminent Domain and the Border.

The 5th Amendment to the US Constitution trumps any emergency declaration.

For the math nerds: Private Property Protection > Emergency Declrations. 

“Similarly, lawyers should be screaming, “The United States government does not have the capability of taking private lands on this scale because of limitations imposed by the Fifth Amendment.”’

Above the Law | Can All Lawyers Just Admit The Wall Will Never Be Built Because Of The Fifth Amendment?

 

Eminent Domain. Church Land. Texas Court Case. Pre-condemnation Access.

The land at issue: On the border with Mexico is owned by the Catholic Church

Where are we in the process? The Bishop denied access to the land for surveying.

The court case: federal district court in McAllen. The church is currently receiving legal assistance from Georgetown University Law School.

The issue: Does the church’s religious convictions trump any taking for a public purpose.

KVEO | Major Law School Helps Church Caufht in Border Wall’s Path

3 Policy Issues. Eminent Domain and Wildlife.

The federal government’s Texas border wall illumates 3 eminent domain issues that impoact wildlife. 

The border wall is planned to run through the National Butterfly Center, a reserve for residential and migratory birds and butterflies and the impact to wildlife has been:

  • Access.  Surveyors have left gates open after deaprting the facility
  • Changes to wildlife environment. equipment and stakes impact sanctuary grounds
  • Communication  Communication between the surveyors and the wildlife center…

3 Eminent Domain Cost Drivers for Texas border wall

  • The route does not follow the river, is a straight line and makes 1000s of acres unusable
  • Unwilling Landowner Litigation the route makes it necessary to take more land from 100s of unwilling landowners
  • Religious land taking a historic Catholic mission will set up a lengthy legal fight over the 1st amendment freedom religion rights of the church vs. the government’s 5th amendment aility to use the power of eminent domain

The Monitor | EDITORIAL: Holy war: Government should reconsider planned…

Legal TREND. Border Wall. Taking Land from the Diocese.

What? On October 25, 2018 teh federal government notified the Diocese of the taking of 2 properties

Which properties are impacted? La Lomita Chapel & property south of the Juan Diego Academy in Mission

the public purpose?

  • conduct surveying
  • testing
  • investigatory work for proposed construction of roads, fencing, vehicle barriers, security lighting, cameras, sensors and related structures to secure the border

compensation to the Diocese?  initial estimate for reimbursement at $100

What’s the…

Eminent Domain = Crony Capitalism Economic Development. 3 examples

 

  • increased economic activity from eminent domain projects are not always realized
    • for example, the land taken in Kelo v. New London remains vacant
  • In Wisconsin eminent domain is being used for a FoxConn economic development project
    • After the use of eminent domain, the same taxpayers will subsize FoxConn salaries 17 cents on the dollar
  • the border wall showcases that not all landwoners are receiving adequate compensation amind allegations tha tonly wealthy landwoners are being…

Campaign TREND. Buzzwords supporting eminent domain reform.

A West Virigina Congressional race features opposition to eminent domain for a pipeline with messaging that

  • shows conservatives and liberals agree in their opposition
  • the public sees no benefit when their land is taken for a pipeline
  • the public sees no benefit when, gasp!, the gas moves overseas

When is eminent domain permissible to the candidates?

  • “clear and strong public benefit”
  • no revolving door from oila nd gas agency oversight to oil and gas industry work

WVTF | 9th Congressional…

5 Big Property Rights & Eminent Domain Cases in Texas. Foreshadowing 2019.