How the Palmetto State Frames No Eminent Domain for Private Gain

What’s happening in South Carolina? The South Carolina Legislature is headed to restrict or limit eminent domain for pipelines.

This is how the Republican Chairman of the Substantive Committee is framing the issue:

  • “Regardless of what we do with eminent domain” (a ban or harder regulator standards)
  • “the pipeline companies can still negotiate with landowners”
  • “to purchase an easement or right of way, or buy the property outright” (pipelines have options)
  • “We are talking about private,…

Peach State Bill Sets Up 2 Step Process for Private Entities & Eminent Domain.

Georgia’s Senate Bill 191  sets up this 2 step process for a pipeline to obtain eminent domain:

  • receive a “certificate of need” from the Georgia Environmental Finance Authority; AND
  • approval by Georgia’s environmental agency 

A late amendment prohbited pipelines in coastal areas, the Georgia Coastal Zone Management Program, to “protect the drinking water.”

Atlanta Journal Constitution | Georgia Senate approves new pipeline limits

Show Me State. Show Me Property Rights. 3 Points informed: intel

  • demand responsible routing of utilities along property lines, boundary lines or section lines
  • require minimized land damage
  • Limits the amount of PSI exerted on soil

What supporters say: “protects our property rights from those who would steal our land for their own profit.”

How does the bill apply? It applies to all condeming entities BUT only to agricultural land.

Missouri HB 640 (2017)

Southeast Missourian | Mo. Agricultural bills

1st Amendment Protections in Eminent Domain. Case Study on Religion Owned Land.

Where: West Virginia

The eminent domain project: A gas pipeline

The religion owned land: Hare Krishna community

The 1st amendment argument: “infringement on its freedom of religion rights and “seeks to take a non-metaphorical bulldozer through the Vrindaban Parties’ property, and in turn, through their most sincerely held holy sites.”

The property to be taken:  50-foot-wide right of way about 3,000 feet long

The Offer: $7,000

Stay Tuned.

Power Source | Gas pipeline raises freedom of…

Private Property Rights: Eminent Domain by 1000 Property Fines. 3 Steps to Nouveau Eminent Domain.

Which city is subject to an Institute for Justice lawsuit for fining its way to eminent domain? Charlestown, Indiana

What’s the alleged nouveau eminent domain use? Fining property owners out of their homes for minor infractions, like a torn screen. Its a bludgeoning by the housing code.

What happened after 1000s in fines accrued? The city made offers to land owners that the fines would be waived if the property owner sold their property to a developer for $10,000.

Institute for Justice…

State Law Prohibits Eminent Domain for Private Gain. How do Pipes and Lines get built?

The State: Pennsylvania

The eminent domain prohibition: no eminent domain for private enterprise, even if there is a public use

The pipeline project: An interstate liquid natural gas pipeline is subject to federal law that allows for eminent domain even when state law prohibits it

Penn Live | Second Sunoco pipeline possible in Cumberland County, landowner continues fight

Eminent Domain by Private Entities is Crony Capitalism.

Tyler Morning Telegraph editorial opposing Texas Centrail Rail raises these 3 points:

  • This isn’t a rural-urban issue. This is a property rights issue.
  • You can’t say this is a private enterprise, promoting free market when you use eminent domain, because eminent domain is the opposite of free market.
  • This is crony capitalism with the government  “thumb on the scale”

Tyler Morning Telegraph | Editorial: Texas bullet train an example of crony capitalism

5 Bills + 5 Companion Bills. Eminent Domain Reform for Rail Only.

A legislator coalition joined forces to limit eminent domain for high speed rail. Who is involved?

  • Senators Birdwell, Creighton,  Kolkhorst, Perry, & Schwertner
  • Representatives Ashby, Bell, Cook, Schubert, and Wray 

Which eminent domain issues are being addressed?

  • Pre-condementation Access to Property. SB 973 by Creighton/HB 2168 by Bell (Railroad Determination Before Surveys) – prohibits a high-speed rail entity from entering private property to conduct a survey unless the Texas Department…