Lege trend: 2 Step Agency Approval for Pipeline Eminent Domain

The South Carolina Attorney General issued an opinion asserting that a pipeline probably does not have eminent domain authority which sent legislators into overdrive. 

The proposal floating around would require an oil and gas comapny to get approval from:

  • The head of the state Department of Health and Environmental Control
  • The head of the  Public Service Commission (its  7  members are elected by the Legislature)

Augusta Chronicle

Virginia General Assembly Races Dominated by No Eminent Domain for Private Gain.

The use of eminent domain for private gain, or in other words, the use of eminent domain by private comapnies like pipelines or transmission lines is dominating state assembly races.

It’s not just Rs and Ds rebuking pipelines for different reasons. Rs support private property rights. Ds are exhibiting a greater concern for environmental issues.

But, it’s also Libertarians, who are actively and viably challenging Republicans. 

The News & Advance | Lynchburg VA

Legal Trend: Pre-condemnation Access from the Buckeye State

11 Ohio counties are in the path of a proposed pipeline that has solidified citizen action in opposition to the pipeline.

The pipeline has been trying for 1 year to access property for normal pre-condemnation access to  properties. It hasn’t worked.

So, the pipeline filed suit, because people who are already heated over their desire to protect private property also love lawsuits. Not the best logic to gain support, but reasonable legal argument if public support is irrelevant.

What are…

Trend: Organized Protesting Eminent Domain Against Private Company

The  Iowa Citizens for Community Improvement joined a coalition called, Bakken Pipeline Resistance Coalition. It sounds like Occupy movement, which recently started promoting anti-eminetn domain causes, like this.

But, Iowa Citizens for Community Improvement is led by a 67 year old, retired former Department of Natural Resources official. 

The whole shebang is encouraging more private negotiations. Iowa posts online negotiated easements, and the company cites 60% of the land being…

AG Opinion from the Palmetto State: No eminent domain for oil & gas

In a long attorney general opinion, relying on case law from Nevada to Florida, the attorney general of South Carolina has issued an opinion that an oil and gas pipeline in all likelihood does not get the privilege of eminent domain.

The opinion discusses South Carolina Courts, and other courts, striking down eminent domain for private companies. 

Its a trend that has been sweeping the nation from courts to legislatures. Everyone is looking for a public use connected to the land that is…

Denbury 6+ Years of Common Carrier Status in Dispute

Earlier this month, Denbury appealed the most recent appellate decision in its case aginst Texas Rice Land Partners. Denbury argues that the Court of Appeals did not follow the Texas Supreme Court’s test for common carrier, estbalished by this lengthy legal saga.

Denbury goes on to argue that the TX Supreme Court has new common carrier issues it needs to look at too. Such as- Is there common carrier status in §2.105 of the Texas Business Organizations Code?

Common Carrier: …