8 Property Rights Points from Rural Land Owners. Pipelines from Permian Basin to the Texas Gulf.

A lawyer representing rural landowners writes:

  • Private for-profit companies are given the government’s power to take private property under assumptions that this is good, common good
  • Are we rubber stamping common good projects for public use/benefit?
  • Why are we taking land before the process is approved by the courts?
  • We need to look at the costs and benefits of eminent domain
  • What happens to old pipelines and how does this get factored into the costs and benefits?
  • Landowners are in an…

Eminent Domain Compensation. How Does a Private taking By a Pipeline Differ from Wind or Solar Energy?

A taking of private land by a private company for a pipeline results in no compensation from royalties, unlike a taking of property for solar or wind energy

CWB Radio | Clark County Board of Supervisors Approves Resolution Asking Wisconsin to Review Eminent Domain Laws

Local TREND. County Resolution Calling for Statewide Eminent Domain Reform. Pipeline Edition

Where: Clark Co. Wisconsin

The resolution is in respopnse to: Enbridge Energy Company’s desire to increase oil capacity traveling through their pipeline system

The rational for changing eminent doamin laws for private companies:

  • A taking of private land by a private company because property owners  receive no royalties, unlike for solar or wind energy
  • Taking property for pipelines greatly reduces property values and tax base

CWB Radio | Clark County Board of Supervisors Approves Resolution…

3 Opposition Talking Points. Land Use. Ballot Proposition Backed by Farmers + Oil & Gas

Which state has this ballot proposition? Colorado Inititative 108 (2018)

What groups are backing the initiative? Colorado Farm Bureau & Oil and Gas Industry

What does the ballot proposition do? Switches compensation calculation to a fair market value standard

The opposition: Cities, Counties

Opposition Says the proposition will:

  •  spawn countless lawsuits
  • it will tie the hands of local governments and prevent any zoning or ordinances
  • we don’t know the unintended consequences

The Gazette…

Natural Resources. Private Condemnation. How to Condemn Minerals & Water

Why do mountain states allow for private condemnation for natural resources? to encourage natural resource development

How is the private condemnation used in arid regions?

  • condemnation was used to allow water to be carried distances over land held by others to irrigate potentially fertile farmland
  • condemnation prevents a single landowner who controls access to a water source or mineral deposit could block development or hold the resources hostage by demanding a significant payout for…

10 States that Recognize Private Condemnations

What is private condemnation?  It allows  landowners the unique ability to condemn another landowner’s property to acquire a right-of-way to construct “ditches, canals and flumes for the purpose of conveying water for domestic purposes,” and for irrigation, mining, manufacturing and drainage, “upon payment of just compensation,”

Which states allow for private condemnation? 

  • Colorado
  • Idaho
  • Wyoming
  • Arizona
  • Montana
  • Nevada
  • Oklahoma
  • Utah
  • North Dakota
  • South Dakota 

Colorado Real Estate…

Compensation for Laws & Regulations That Reduce Property Value. Anatomy of a Constitutional Amendment:

Colorado Farm Bureau is proposing Initiative 108 that will amend the Colorado Constitution to:

  • “ensure property owners are properly compensated if new laws or regulations negatively impact the value of their property”

What is the catalyst? tightening of setbacks on oil and gas development from fracking proliferation

How does the tightening of oil and gas setbacks impact farmers?  Setbacks essentially eliminate oil and natural gas development & farmers rely on royalty checks

Journal Advocate…

Legal TREND. LNG Exports and Property Rights. 4 Key Points to Know Now for Legislation later.

What issue are legal property rights centers looking at?  is there a public good, for eminent domain purposes,  when the public that benefits from the exported good is Europe or China?

What does this have to do with eminent domain? Pipelines, such as those that feed a LNG Export Center, are often uilt with the use of the power of eminent domain.

To exercize eminent domain constitutionally there must be a public use/public purpose for the land

How are property rights legal exeperts looking to…

Legal Trend. Pre-condemnation Access. Landowners Need Opportunity to Negotiate via the flowering dogwood state. What you need to know:

Background: Atlantic Coast Pipeline contractors seek access to property to begin tree-cutting, Landowners are asking a court to prevent the tree cutting.

What court? US District Court Judge Terence Boyle, a George HW Bush appointee, in the Eastern District of North Carolina

The court sides with the landowners and said: 

  • landowners should have a reasonable opportunity to negotiate
  • the pipeline can use eminent domain

What pre-requisities on eminent domain use are detailed by the court to…

Legal TREND. Are Private Entities Using Eminent Domain Subject to Open Records?

A Louisiana Court ruled that  Public Records Laws Not Applicable To Private Pipeline Company.

Arguments for Open Records: If the entity performs a governmental role, like taking property, it should be subject to open records

The Court’s response— there is no basis for applying open records requirements in this matter.

Red River Radio | Judge Rules Public Records Laws Not Applicable To Private Pipeline Company