2015 Media Top 10: Eminent Domain in the Palmetto State

Eminent domain tops the headlines for 2015 in South Carolina.

What’s the eminent domain issue in South Carolina? A pipeline that caused private proeprty right activist snd environmental activists to join forces.

What’s the legislative and regulatory impact? The issue with the pipeline is whether a public benefit occurs in South Carolina. The pipeline has hit hiccups with the regulatory agency and the legislature. 

The Augusta Chronicler | Top 10: Palmetto Pipeline creates stir in 2015

Eminent domain, heroin top capital city stories for 2015

The Barre Montpelier Times Argus headline that needs to introduction for putting eminent domain and heroin in the same sentence: Eminent domain, heroin top capital city stories for 2015.

But, seriously, what’s the eminent domain issue?  A bike path that displaced a business and caused all residents at a public meeting to speak against the use of eminent domain.

Lege Trend: Eastern State Seeks to Up Relocation Costs for Farmers, Businesses, Residential & Renters.

What state, that’s NOT California, is looking to increase relocation costs? Pennsylvania

What are the current relocation cost rates in PA?  

  • For businesses the cap is $12, 000.
  • For private home owners the damage cap for relocation costs is $27,000.
  • For tenants, the damage cap is $6,300

What damage cap rates for relocation costs in PA considering?

  • $25,000 for businesses
  • $31,000 for residential owners
  • $7,200 for tenants

Fox Rothschild | PA considering Increasing Condemnee…

Protestors Stop an Eminent Domain Public Meeting for a Pipeline

Where is this happening? Vermont

Why does this matter in Texas? Because 2015 saw emient domain protestors stop public meetings for transportation projects in Texas

Who is the opposition to eminent domain in VT? 98% of a VT Gas project has agreed-to sales for land, but 3 landowners have not come to an agreement with VT Gas.

What does the opposition want from the pipelines? Landowners and their supporters are calling on a shorter pipeline project & are concerned baout pipeline safety

…

Trend: Right and Left Talking Same Eminent DomainReforms in Iowa Elections. 3 Targets.

The usual suspects- Ted Cruz, Rand Paul, Rubio talk eminent domain reform on the campaign trail. Now Bernie Sanders has joined the fray by saying :

“Iowans shouldn’t have their land forcibly taken through eminent domain for use in the proposed Bakken oil pipeline.”

“”The idea of using the power of eminent domain to increase private profits does not make a lot of sense to me,” he said.”

Sounds just like the right’s – no private gain from eminent domain- mantra.

Des Moines Register…

Trend: Eminent Domain Reform. Private Entities Using Eminent Domain in Crosshairs.

South Carolina’s 2016 legislative session and eminent domain reform is on the list.

What group is targeting eminent domain by private entities? The Republican Caucus for the South Carolina House.

What reforms do South Carolina Republicans want?

  • tighten public use so that land “will never be diverted to private control”

Bluffton Today | What to expect in the next session

How a $244K property payment by a Sewer District became a $12M property owner award + $4M in attorney fees.

What’s this eminent domain case about? New York’s Rockland County Sewer District No. 1 needs to build a new wastewater treatment facility & sought to acquire 21 acres.

What did the court decide? The property is worth $8,100,000 plus $4,762,187 interest, a total of $12,877,061. PLUS, the court awarded $$3,375,000  in legal and appraisal fees.

What did the sewer district estimate the cost of the project to be?  $72 Million. After this court case, the project estiamte is $181…

Hess Triangle. How Eminent Domain Battle Created NYC's Smallest Piece of Property. Hint: Check Your Property Surveys Before you Condemn.

What’s Hess Triangle? A triangular piece of property that is 25.5 inches by 27.5 inches by 27.5 inches. 

What? How can this two foot triangle exist as private property in NYC? Go to corner of Seventh Avenue and Christopher Street and you’ll see it

How did this small piece of property emerge from an eminent domain fight? In 1910, NYC was extending the Seventh Avenue Subway Line. A property owner named Hess owned a 5 story building in the path of the new subway extension.

What did the…

4 Takeaways from an Activist Private Property Rights Group

Where is the private property rights group forming? Mt. Airy North Carolina

What type of project sparked the group’s formation? A local redevelopment plan

What’s the group’s goal? To remove private property from the local redevelopment plan

Why? The local government’s plan to redevelop land that it holds, expanded to include private property of a former city council candidate

What concerns about eminent domain does the group have?

  • That the use of eminent domain will result in…

4 Reasons Midwestern Elected Officials Oppose Eminent Domain for Transmission Lines. Localizing Public Benefit.

State Rep. Grassley, grandson to US Senator Grassley, has 2 points to make to a clean energy line that wants to use eminent domain in Iowa:

  • The Iowa Utilities Board has told you 2 times that eminent domain cannot be separated from your permit application
  • If you don’t allow Iowans to plug in, you’re not a utility & therefore don’t deserve eminent domain powers
  • Missouri also denied your transmission line request (our numbers are growing)
  • We’re also watching your attempt to end run the…