Legal Trend: Appeals Court denies Eminent Domain Authority to Pipeline. The 3 Private Property Rights Arguments.

Joining other courts, which appelate court denied immediate eminent domain authority for a pipeline? A Pennsylvania appeals court

What argument is made to deny eminent domain authority to the pipeline? 

  • The pipeline has not obtained approval from the state agency that must approve a certificate of convenience and necessity to trigger eminent domain authority
  • Plus, the pipeline is interstate
    • so it can’t be regulated by the state
    • and, there is no interstate eminent domain authority
  • There is no public benefit to Pensylvania because the goods carried on the pipeline will be used for export

State Impact Pennsylvania | Appeals court clears way for eminent domain suit against Sunoco Logistics